Coming out of the cold of May - Shepherd's Pie with Horseradish Mash
Friday, May 4, 2012 at 9:38AM 
Solly and Grandma draw in hopes of better weather.
It’s May 3 in Seattle. My lilacs are finally blooming, the late tulips have a few days left and the lawn needs a mow. It is also the same May, the time that the weather rears its temperamental head in ugly way – all those apple blossoms you are coveting – whooshed away by the stiff breezes, driving around wearing a skort bare legged and flip flops with the heater blasting on my feet. Seattle, after all is the home of the four season cashmere sweater.
Many blogs and instagram feeds are full of lovely spring treats – baby peas, rhubarb, spring chickens with poached asparagus and tiny little salad greens. That is all lovely and so luscious and cold. Brr. This kind of weather calls for a hearty dish that sticks to our freezing ribs and maybe uses up the last of the root vegetables that are moldering in the back of the refrigerator crisper. The first thing that comes to mind when I look up at the dark, damp and grey of a Seattle afternoon is a Shepherd’s pie. My friend Paola, makes a proper British Shepherd’s Pie with lamb and all that, I tend to stray to the American version, fashioned after Elise Bauer’s Simply Recipes delicious beef filled one. In making mine, I tried to use what I had on hand, which were a few wizened turnips, rutabagas and carrots that I was excited about in January, but not so much in April. Root vegetables make the winter to spring transition in Seattle interminable.
Wizened veggies from the crisper.
Shepherd’s pie is pretty basic, take some sort of minced meat product, slightly season it, add whatever root vegetable you have on hand, mix it together and top with a potato crust. Bake and serve. It freezes beautifully and tastes better the following day. It is a leftover I actually look forward to eating. It can be fancied up with cheese or more spice, but I like it left a little plain. I have substituted turkey meat for the beef, but it is not as flavorful. I suppose if you loved ground lamb, then a mix of beef and lamb would be even tastier. The potato crust is where you can get really crazy – add cheese, garlic, jalapenos (I hear Paola shuddering), herbs or just keep it simple. The key is to make sure the crust gets a little crispy and the mixture h piping hot all the way through.
The mince and the ridges.
As I finish writing this up, the rain is drumming against our windows. Ernest refuses to go out and I can’t blame him. It is better to dream about a sunnier tomorrow.
Shepherd’s Pie with Horse radish Mashed Potato Crust (adapted from Elise Bauer’s Simply Recipes Shepherd’s Pie)
Makes one pie, feeds 6 with no leftovers
Meat filling
1 ½ lb. ground beef (I used 15% fat)
1 medium onion, chopped – yielding 1 cup
3 carrots (more if you don’t have other root vegetables), chopped
1 medium turnip, chopped
1 medium rutabaga, chopped
1 parsnip (if you have it), chopped
1 c frozen peas
½ cup water or stock
2 T butter or fat of choice for sautéing the vegetable mixture
1 T Worcestershire sauce
1 t fines herbes or some sort of herb mix containing (savory, thyme, marjoram)
½ t salt or more to taste
Pepper to taste
Mashed potato crust:
1 ½ lbs of Yukon gold or new potatoes, washed and halved or cubed depending on size
1/3 cup Greek yoghurt, sour cream or what you wish as creamy liquid
1 T creamed horseradish, or less if it’s hot
1 T butter
Under medium heat, melt butter in generously sized sauté pan. Add onions and cook for five minutes, or until they soften. Add carrots and other root vegetables and sauté for another 10 minutes to soften. Mix in fines herbes or herb mix to the vegetables. In a separate pan, boil chopped potatoes until fork tender (15 minutes). Remove from heat, drain and set aside. Crumble beef into the vegetable mixture, cover pan and cook until meat is no longer pink (approximately another seven minutes), add water moisten the mixture if it is dry. Remove from heat, add peas and Worcestershire sauce and season to taste.
Note: Add peas late, because you want them to stay nice and green. I can’t cotton to grey peas in this dish. They will cook when the rest of the dish is assembled and baked. Ditto for the vegetables, you don’t want to over cook them because they will be mushy. 4 out of 5 Shepherds prefer their vegetables to be cooked just right.
Coarsely mash potatoes you have set aside with a potato masher (you may actually have one in the back of your utensil drawer) or a fork. Add yoghurt, butter and creamed horseradish and mash some more (you may still want some chunky bits in your potatoes). Season the mashed potatoes to taste with salt and pepper.
In a buttered or oiled 2.5 quart baking dish (I used a something like this), pour in the beef and vegetable mixture. Top with mashed potatoes mixture spreading as best as you can to the edges. Elise suggests making pretty wavy patterns that ensure more browned and crispy bits and I second that. Bake at 375 F for 30 minutes until hot and burbly and the top starts to get golden brown, but does not burn.
In our household, we would pair this with a green salad and a side of cottage cheese. Yup, cottage cheese and it is delicious, just ask TH.
Reader Comments (3)
I bookmarked this nice recipe you have, and will attempt it when the craving for shepherds pie becomes too strong to bear. I will update you on how successful I am. This looks like a lot of hard procedures, so I hope I will manage it! The pictures look delicious. Maybe you can bring me a sample sometime in class ;)